| |  | Author: Lucy Grealy
Publisher: Topeka Bindery
Category: Book
List Price: $23.30
Buy New: $18.17
You Save: $5.13 (22%)
New (1) Used (3) from $16.98
Avg. Customer Rating:  93 reviews
Sales Rank: 3445894
Media: School & Library Binding
Number Of Items: 1
Shipping Weight (lbs): 0.6
Dimensions (in): 7.4 x 5.1 x 0.8
ISBN: 0613648390
Dewey Decimal Number: 362.1969947160092
EAN: 9780613648394
ASIN: 0613648390
Publication Date: July 2003
Availability: Usually ships in 24 hours
|
| Customer Reviews:
 Lucy overcomes extreme adversity at a young age March 29, 2008
0 out of 1 found this review helpful
I originally had to read this book for a school project, and I wasn't expecting much since I usually don't find non fiction very interesting. But this book wasn't bad, it was pretty good. This girl Lucy, at nine, crashes into another kid's head playing a game during recess, and her face begins to hurt way more than it should and then swells up. She goes to the doctor and she finds out she has a tumor in her jaw, and that its cancerous. However, this book is really not about Lucy's cancer. It's about her life and the effect that the cancer has on it. At first, she really doesn't mind that much. She likes all the special attention that she is getting, and doesn't care what she looks like, even with one whole third of her jaw removed. Later however, she becomes very insecure about her face and becomes obsessed with multiple reconstructive surgeries that never work, convinced that she can never be loved with a face like hers. She finds it easier to spend time with the horses she works with at her high school job than with people. She eventually gets her face fixed (somewhat), but she thinks it's all wrong, that its not really her. I liked this because it was informative without being "whiney" and I would recommend it to anyone who enjoys biographies about people overcoming adversity. It is also a good book for high school girls who are insecure about their looks, because it shows them how lucky they really are to be "whole". I suppose something like what happened to Lucy can really mess you up, but she comes out fine in the end because she learns how to deal with her appearance issues. It's a good book.
 Autobiography of a Face January 27, 2008
0 out of 1 found this review helpful
a little wrinkled, but the text is what matters and it is a great read.... if you are into depressing stories....
Moving, engaging, darkly troubling, and inspiring - made me want to appreciate the simple joys of life January 9, 2008
1 out of 1 found this review helpful
IMPRESSIONS:
This was a good book, moving and engaging. Though you would think that it was the battle with cancer itself which would prove troublesome, perhaps because of the young age at which she underwent this struggle, we see that it the resulting effects are what truly impacted Grealy's life.
Her book is insightful even for those who have not had to undergo the extraordinary struggles that she faced. The desire to be loved and feel special, to want to stand out in a singular and unique way and yet not be ridiculed, but rather adored, the simple joy that comes from being able to look at someone and know that they are looking back and see you and know you and understand you, loving you all the while, these emotions run throughout this book and would echo with anyone who has not always felt loved or accepted, who has doubted their worthiness.
CRITICISMS:
I did find that Grealy's siblings were quite absent throughout her narrative. She had four siblings, one of them a fraternal twin, and I found it quite odd that we don't really see that much of them or are given very clear depictions of them - especially her twin sister, Sarah, since all of the twins I've known have always been extremely close with their sibling.
I also found her father's death kind of glossed over and was unable to understand the detachment with which it was written about. That she only visited her father once in the hospital while he was there for a few months seemed incomprehensible to me, but who am I to judge another's grief or how they display it? Grealy later writes of finally feeling the loss of her father, and the regret with which she writes of that moment when she lay in her hospital bed, pretending sleep, and he walked softly in, was very moving and could be acutely felt.
As some other reviewers have mentioned, however, the book is entitled "Autobiography of a Face," and that is what you are getting.
OF NOTE:
As I was writing this review, I was doing some research online and found out that Lucy Grealy passed away in 2002. Apparently, the brief drug dependency mentioned in passing in "Autobiography of a Face" reemerged later in life and led to a presumed accidental drug overdose. She was close friends with Ann Patchett, author of "Bel Canto," and there has been some controversy surrounding Patchett's 2004 memoir, "Truth & Beauty," which recounts the friendship of the two authors (apparently Grealy's family objects to Patchett's portrayal of her).
The article "Hijacked by grief," by Grealy's sister Suellen, which appeared in the August 7, 2004 edition of the Guardian (and can be found online) was enlightening not only on the family's reaction to Patchett's depictions of Lucy Grealy, but also on the Lucy Grealy herself, in that in an odd way it seemed to offer a missing piece of anything that might have been lacking in Grealy's own account. It greatly altered my previous opinion of Patchett and it also reminded me, both in regards to Patchett's memoir and Grealy's, that any narrative or autobiography writes of other people and that though what may be written is a truthful depiction of what the author felt and experienced, every person detailed has their own story, that somewhere where all of these accounts intersect is some semblance of accuracy and all we can do is understand the deficiency of our own portrayals and appreciate that which can be told.
OTHER REVIEWS:
(This is just a wrap-up of what other people seem to commonly find praise or fault with in this book.)
Positive reviews mentioned the following ...
- Beautifully written and inspiring
- Difficult to read in its honesty and "heartbreaking words"
- "As Grealy shows us in her memoir, she was never different from anyone else: she was always just as imperfect, and beautiful, as we are" (J. Babcock)
- Evokes emotion and empathy, very thought-provoking
- A candid story of the tragedy of cancer and how one woman was able to deal with it all at such a young age, but overcome it in the end
- Accurate criticism of our society's obsession with beauty and looks and that these qualify and determine our worth and lovability
Negative reviews mentioned the following ...
- The book was a long diatribe of self-pity
- She continually and singularly dwells on her own physical ugliness (disregarding the pain of others, that she should be thankful to be alive, etc.)
- Not enough details on other aspects of Lucy Grealy's life were included, no outside story or information on her family, too "one-dimensional" etc.
Humor in dark places November 12, 2007
1 out of 1 found this review helpful
Lucy Grealy said it best herself when fans asked her how she remembered everything in such detail. She said, "I didn't remember it. I wrote it." And the result is beautiful, haunting and oddly funny. Grealy delves into the dark with such wit that even descriptions of chemo-induced vomiting and the cruelties of adolescent boys become bearable. The great tragedy is that we lost her so soon...
Too depressing November 5, 2007
4 out of 4 found this review helpful
I thought I'd read this after my jaw was removed because of a tumor. Just depressed me even more because the author had it even worse than I did. Want to suffer more than you thought you have? Then read this. Suffered enough? Go out and enjoy the sunshine instead.
|
|
|
Powered by Associate-O-Matic
| |
